The Bakery ~ Mouth Watering Goodness

 

 

Home

 

Online Store

 

Dining

 

Bakery

      

Gift Shop

 

Banquets

 

Catering

 

Contact Us

 

 

 

     The bakery is the heart of Mary Yoder's.  From the bakery comes the aroma of fresh baked bread, apple butter simmering, or pies just out of the oven.  All the wonderful homemade desserts people enjoy in the dining room come fresh from our bakery.

Everyone can find his or her favorite pie at Mary Yoder's. Whether you like Dutch apple, elderberry, strawberry rhubarb, or chocolate cream, you will not be disappointed. For a complete list of pies, click here.

We have a wide variety of home baked cookies from which to choose. Favorites like chocolate chip and peanut butter are always available, or treat yourself to a chocolate cookie dough brownie or a raisin filled cookie.  Cookie trays are available at Christmas, or for any special occasion. For a list of available cookies, click here.

All the bread served in the dining room is baked in our bakery by Amish bakers.  Choose from white, honey wheat, rye, sour dough, or pepperoni bread.  Take home a loaf of banana, pumpkin, or cranberry nut bread to enjoy later. The homemade rolls (white or wheat) that you enjoy in the dining room are available to take home from our bakery.

If you have never tasted Amish Wedding cake, also called date nut pudding, you don't know what you are missing! We also have chocolate cake, carrot cake and decorated cakes available for your special occasion.

One of the many wonderful foods made in the bakery is our Amish peanut butter spread, a wonderful blend of peanut butter, marshmallow cream, and other ingredients. Eaten on a cracker, or as a topping for ice cream or on our homemade bread, hundreds of people enjoy it every week.

Another exceptionally good taste from our bakery is our homemade apple butter. Slowly simmered all day and canned in pint jars, it is a wonderful Amish treat. Both the apple butter and the peanut butter spread can be ordered at our online store.