Amish Bakery at Mary Yoders

Our bakery is the heart of the Mary Yoder's experience. The aroma of fresh baked bread, apple butter simmering, or pies just out of the oven! All of the wonderful homemade desserts our guests enjoy in our dining room come fresh from our bakery!

Everyone will find a favorite pie at Mary Yoders. Dutch Apple, Elderberry, Strawberry Rhubarb or Chocolate Cream, you won't be disappointed!

We also offer a wide variety of home baked cookies. Favorites like Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter and Oatmeal Raisin are always available, or treat yourself to an Almond Bar or Raisin Filled Cookie.

Cookie trays are available for Christmas or any other special occasion.

Our Homemade Pie List

Extra Deep 10" Pies

Apple
Dutch Apple
Blackberry
Blueberry
Bumbleberry
Cherry
Cherry Crumb
Custard
Elderberry
German Chocolate
Mince
Peach
Pecan
Pumpkin
Pumpkin Nut
Raisin
Red Raspberry
Rhubarb
Rhubarb Crumb
Schnitz
Strawberry Rhubarb
Toll House

Extra Deep 10" Cream Pies

Banana Cream
Butterscotch Cream
Chocolate Cream
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream
Coconut Cream
Lemon Cream
Peanut Butter Cream
Raspberry Cream

Sugar Free Pies

Apple
Blackberry
Blueberry
Cherry
Elderberry
Pumpkin
Red Raspberry
Rhubarb

Pies are available upon request. Call ahead to place your order! We ask for a 24 hour notice for orders.

Our Homemade Cookie List

Drop Cookies

Chocolate Chip
Ginger
Maple
Molasses
Monster
Oatmeal Butterscotch
Oatmeal Raisin
Peanut Butter
Peanut Butter Cups
Raisin Filled
Raisin Puffs
Snickerdoodles
Spell Binders
Sugar Cookies

Bar Cookies

Almond Bars
Brownies
Butterscotch Cream Cheese Bars
Can't Leave Alone Bars
Lemon Bars
M&M Dream Bars
Pumpkin Bars
Revel Bars
Twix Bars
Walnut Chewies

Christmas Cookies (Seasonal)

Almond Maraschino Whites
Chocolate Crinkles
Ginger Snaps
Oatmeal Jammys
Orange Snickerdoodles
Peanut Butter Blossoms
Peppermint Chip
Russian Tea Cakes
Sugar Cookies
Pie Dough Pinwheels

Cookies for trays are available by the pound and can include drop cookies of your choice.