Monday thru Saturday
7am to 8pm
14743 North State Street
Middlefield OH 44062


mary roders sugar free pie elderberry
Mary Yoders Sugar Free Amish Pie - Elderberry

Those who watch their sugar intake can still enjoy an Amish made pie from Mary Yoder's. The Amish ladies in our bakery use Splenda to sweeten many of our most requested pies. Choose from apple, blueberry, blackberry, cherry, elderberry, red raspberry and rhubarb.


Sorry, we are temporarily out of elderberries.  Check back in October!


QUESTIONS? Give us a call at 440.632.1939 and we can help you find exactly what you need!