Mon thru Thurs, 6am to 7pm
Fri thru Sat, 6am to 8pm
Closed Sunday
14743 North State Street
Middlefield OH 44062


What Mary Yoder's Amish Kitchen Customers Say

Please take a moment to look at what some of our customers have said about their experience at Mary Yoder's Amish Kitchen. Whether breakfast, lunch or dinner, we strive to make every visit the best we have to offer.

Thanks for considering a visit to our restaurant, bakery and gift shop!



Your bakery and food service is the best Thank you Mary Yoder's is always a great reason for a road trip
I would patronize this establishment 7 days a week if that were feasible! Unfortunately I live about 40 miles away, but anytime I'm even near the area I make it a point to stop in for a meal. The food is beyond outstanding in quality, price and value, and the staff is exceptionally diligent and friendly. If you haven't been there, you're missing out!
I ordered 3 elderberry pies and thought I would send an email thanking you. First, the extraordinary care and layers of packaging really impressed me. The pies were in perfect condition on arrival. Not a crumb out of place. I put two pies in the freezer and we are currently enjoying the sugar free pie. It is probably one of the best pies i have ever eaten. I was a little leary of ordering a fragile pie to be mailed, but those concerns were unnecessary. And, best of all, the pie is wonderful. I will definitely order again in the future.
My husband surprised me with a little road trip last week for our anniversary. It’s about a two hour drive to your restaurant. We had heard such good things about your place that we were glad to finally get there. When I mentioned to our nice waitress that it was our anniversary, she said it was hers too….same day, same year. What are the odds? Anyway, we ordered the meatloaf and agree that it’s the best meatloaf we’ve ever had. My feelings might have been a little hurt since I’ve been making him meatloaf for all these 37 years. But, I had to agree. Really delicious!
First time visitor definitely going back. Food was amazing waitress was amazing as was everyone who works there. You definitely will not leave hungry. We just love this place its beyond amazing.
Drove 2.5 hours from NY yesterday so my fiancee could try it..he loved it and so did I. we got the chicken and roast beef family style dinners and the stuffing, beef and chicken were amazing. Also the waitress was helpful and nice. Will make the trip back again for certain. (via Facebook)
I ordered the senior roast beef dinner and my wife ordered the roast turkey dinner. Both meals were more than enough and very good traditional meals, exactly what we wanted! Service and restaurant are excellent. (via Facebook)
A group of about 90 of us showed up with 2 tour buses. They were expecting us and had everything ready for us. The food was really good and the pie so yummy ! Excellent service and a fun gift store. (via Facebook)
I had a half portion of meatloaf with mashed potatoes and gravy and a salad. Everything was delicious! I left full but not bloated. Even got a slice of homemade strawberry rhubarb pie to go! (via Facebook)