Monday, Friday & Saturday
7am to 8pm
Tuesday, Wednesday & Thursday
11am to 8pm
14743 North State Street
Middlefield OH 44062

440.632.1939

Mon, Fri & Sat, 7AM-8PM
Tue, Wed & Thur, 11AM-8PM
14743 North State Street
Middlefield OH 44062
440.632.1939
Home
Menus
Banquets
About
Contact
Gift Shop
Bakery
Store

Bakery from Mary Yoder's Amish Kitchen

Amish Cookies

mrs yoders cookie no bake bars
Mary Yoders - No Bake Bars
MYC-NOBA
$4.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

chocolate chip cookies
Mary Yoders Cookies - Chocolate Chip
MYC-CC
$4.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

Chocolate Crinkle
Mary Yoders Cookies - Chocolate Crinkles
MYC-CHOCCR
$4.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

mary yoders cookie christmas kiss
Mary Yoders Cookies - Christmas Kiss
MYC-CHRIS
$4.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

ginger cookie
Mary Yoders Cookies - Ginger
MYC-GIN
$4.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

maple cookie
Mary Yoders Cookies - Maple
MYC-MAP
$4.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

molasses cookies
Mary Yoders Cookies - Molasses
MYC-MOL
$4.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

monster cookies
Mary Yoders Cookies - Monster
MYC-MON
$4.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

oatmeal butterscotch cookie
Mary Yoders Cookies - Oatmeal Butterscotch
MYC-OATBU
$4.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

oatmeal raisin cookie
Mary Yoders Cookies - Oatmeal Raisin
MYC-OATRAI
$4.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

peanut butter cookie
Mary Yoders Cookies - Peanut Butter
MYC-PB
$4.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

mary yoders cookie peanut butter blossom
Mary Yoders Cookies - Peanut Butter Blossom
MYC-PBBL
$4.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

raisin puff cookie
Mary Yoders Cookies - Raisin Puffs
MYC-RAIP
$4.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

mary yoders cookie russian tea cakes
Mary Yoders Cookies - Russian Tea Cakes
MYC-RUS
$4.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

spell binder cookies
Mary Yoders Cookies - Spell Binders
MYC-SPEL
$4.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

mary yoders cookie thumb prints
Mary Yoders Cookies - Thumbprints
MYC-THUMB
$4.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

white chocolate chip cookies
Mary Yoders Cookies White Chocolate Chip Pretzel
MYC-WCCP
$4.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

oatmeal pie cookie
Oatmeal Pie Cookie
OATPC
$2.29

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

whoopie pie cookie
Whoopie Pie Cookie
WHOOPC
$2.29

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

Amish Cookies - Specialty

raisin filled cookie
Mary Yoders Specialty Cookies - Raisin Filled
MYSC-RAI
$5.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

mary yoders specialty cookies reese peanut butter cup
Mary Yoders Specialty Cookies - Reese Peanut Butter Cup
MYSC-RPBC
$5.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

sugar cookie
Mary Yoders Specialty Cookies - Sugar Cookies
MYSC-S
$5.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

Amish Pies

mary yoders amish pie apple
Mary Yoders Amish Pie - Apple
MYAP-A
$11.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

mary yoders amish pie cherry
Mary Yoders Amish Pie - Cherry
MYAP-C
$11.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

mary yoders amish pie rhubarb
Mary Yoders Amish Pie - Rhubarb
MYAP-R
$11.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

mary yoders amish pie strawberry rhubarb
Mary Yoders Amish Pie - Strawberry Rhubarb
MYAP-SR
$11.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

Amish Pies - Specialty

mary yoders specialty pie blackberry
Mary Yoders Specialty Pie - Blackberry
MYSP-BLA
$12.79

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

mary yoders specialty pie blueberry
Mary Yoders Specialty Pie - Blueberry
MYSP-BLU
$12.79

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

mary yoders specialty pie bumbleberry
Mary Yoders Specialty Pie - Bumbleberry
MYSP-BB
$12.79

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

mary yoders specialty pie elderberry
Mary Yoders Specialty Pie - Elderberry
MYSP-E
$12.79

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

mary yoders specialty pie german chocolate
Mary Yoders Specialty Pie - German Chocolate
MYSP-GC
$12.79

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

mary yoders specialty pie peach
Mary Yoders Specialty Pie - Peach
MYSP-PCH
$12.79

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

Amish Pies - Sugar Free

mary yoders sugar free pie apple
Mary Yoders Sugar Free Amish Pie - Apple
MYSFAP-A
$12.79

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

mary yoders sugar free pie blackberry
Mary Yoders Sugar Free Amish Pie - Blackberry
MYSFAP-BLA
$12.79

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

mary yoders sugar free pie blueberry
Mary Yoders Sugar Free Amish Pie - Blueberry
MYSFAP-BLU
$12.79

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

mary yoders sugar free pie cherry
Mary Yoders Sugar Free Amish Pie - Cherry
MYSFAP-C
$12.79

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

mary roders sugar free pie elderberry
Mary Yoders Sugar Free Amish Pie - Elderberry
MYSFAP-E
$12.79

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

mary roders sugar free pie red raspberry
Mary Yoders Sugar Free Amish Pie - Red Raspberry
MYSFAP-RR
$14.99

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

mary yoders sugar free pie rhubarb
Mary Yoders Sugar Free Amish Pie - Rhubarb
MYSFAP-R
$12.79

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

Sliced Bread

french bread thick sliced
French Bread - Thick Sliced
FBRD-THC
$3.29

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

french bread thin sliced
French Bread - Thin Sliced
FBRD-THN
$3.29

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

honey wheat bread thick sliced
Honey Wheat Bread - Thick Sliced
HWBRD-THC
$3.29

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

honey wheat bread thin sliced
Honey Wheat Bread - Thin Sliced
HWBRD-THN
$3.29

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

multi grain bread thick sliced
Multi Grain Bread - Thick Sliced
MGBRD-THC
$4.29

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

multi grain bread thin sliced
Multi Grain Bread - Thin Sliced
MGBRD-THN
$4.29

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

raisin cinnamon bread thick sliced
Raisin Cinnamon Bread - Thick Sliced
RAIBRD-THC
$3.29

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

raisin cinnamon bread thin sliced
Raisin Cinnamon Bread - Thin Sliced
RAIBRD-THN
$3.29

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

rye bread thick sliced
Rye Bread - Thick Sliced
RBRD-THC
$3.29

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

rye bread thin sliced
Rye Bread - Thin Sliced
RBRD-THN
$3.29

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

sour dough bread thick sliced
Sourdough Bread - Thick Sliced
SBRD-THC
$3.69

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

sour dough bread thin sliced
Sourdough Bread - Thin Sliced
SBRD-THN
$3.69

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

white bread thin sliced
White Bread - Thin Sliced
WBRD-THN
$3.29

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

Unsliced Bread

french bread unsliced
French Bread - Unsliced
FBRD-UN
$3.29

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

honey wheat bread unsliced
Honey Wheat Bread - Unsliced
HWBRD-UN
$3.29

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

multi grain bread unsliced
Multi Grain Bread - Unsliced
MGBRD-UN
$4.29

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

raisin cinnamon bread unsliced
Raisin Cinnamon Bread - Unsliced
RAIBRD-UN
$3.29

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

rye bread unsliced
Rye Bread - Unsliced
RBRD-UN
$3.29

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

sour dough bread unsliced
Sourdough Bread - Unsliced
SBRD-UN
$3.69

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

white bread unsliced
White Bread - Unsliced
WBRD-UN
$3.29

add to cart imageAdd to Cart

Don't see what you need? Let us know and we may add it to our product line!

Home
Login
© 2019. Mary Yoders Amish Kitchen.
Middlefield Burton West Farmington Ohio website design & development by One Meeting Street LLC.