Monday thru Saturday
7am to 8pm
14743 North State Street
Middlefield OH 44062

440.632.1939

Bakery from Mary Yoder's Amish Kitchen

Amish Cookies

Mary Yoders - No Bake Bars

MYC-NOBA

$4.99

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Cookies - Chocolate Chip

MYC-CC

$4.99

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Cookies - Chocolate Crinkles

MYC-CHOCCR

$4.99

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Cookies - Christmas Kiss

MYC-CHRIS

$4.99

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Cookies - Ginger

MYC-GIN

$4.99

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Cookies - Maple

MYC-MAP

$4.99

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Cookies - Molasses

MYC-MOL

$4.99

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Cookies - Monster

MYC-MON

$4.99

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Cookies - Oatmeal Butterscotch

MYC-OATBU

$4.99

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Cookies - Oatmeal Raisin

MYC-OATRAI

$4.99

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Cookies - Peanut Butter

MYC-PB

$4.99

Add to Cart

mary yoders cookie peanut butter blossom

Mary Yoders Cookies - Peanut Butter Blossom

MYC-PBBL

$4.99

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Cookies - Raisin Puffs

MYC-RAIP

$4.99

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Cookies - Russian Tea Cakes

MYC-RUS

$4.99

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Cookies - Spell Binders

MYC-SPEL

$4.99

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Cookies - Thumbprints

MYC-THUMB

$4.99

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Cookies White Chocolate Chip Pretzel

MYC-WCCP

$4.99

Add to Cart

Oatmeal Pie Cookie

OATPC

$2.29

Add to Cart

Whoopie Pie Cookie

WHOOPC

$2.29

Add to Cart

Amish Cookies - Specialty

Mary Yoders Specialty Cookies - Raisin Filled

MYSC-RAI

$5.99

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Specialty Cookies - Reese Peanut Butter Cup

MYSC-RPBC

$5.99

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Specialty Cookies - Sugar Cookies

MYSC-S

$5.99

Add to Cart

Amish Pies

Mary Yoders Amish Pie - Apple

MYAP-A

$11.99

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Amish Pie - Cherry

MYAP-C

$11.99

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Amish Pie - Rhubarb

MYAP-R

$11.99

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Amish Pie - Strawberry Rhubarb

MYAP-SR

$11.99

Add to Cart

Amish Pies - Specialty

Mary Yoders Specialty Pie - Blackberry

MYSP-BLA

$12.79

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Specialty Pie - Blueberry

MYSP-BLU

$12.79

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Specialty Pie - Bumbleberry

MYSP-BB

$12.79

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Specialty Pie - Elderberry

MYSP-E

$12.79

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Specialty Pie - German Chocolate

MYSP-GC

$12.79

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Specialty Pie - Peach

MYSP-PCH

$12.79

Add to Cart

Amish Pies - Sugar Free

Mary Yoders Sugar Free Amish Pie - Apple

MYSFAP-A

$12.79

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Sugar Free Amish Pie - Blackberry

MYSFAP-BLA

$12.79

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Sugar Free Amish Pie - Blueberry

MYSFAP-BLU

$12.79

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Sugar Free Amish Pie - Cherry

MYSFAP-C

$12.79

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Sugar Free Amish Pie - Elderberry

MYSFAP-E

$12.79

Add to Cart

mary roders sugar free pie red raspberry

Mary Yoders Sugar Free Amish Pie - Red Raspberry

MYSFAP-RR

$14.99

Add to Cart

Mary Yoders Sugar Free Amish Pie - Rhubarb

MYSFAP-R

$12.79

Add to Cart

Sliced Bread

French Bread - Thick Sliced

FBRD-THC

$3.29

Add to Cart

French Bread - Thin Sliced

FBRD-THN

$3.29

Add to Cart

Honey Wheat Bread - Thick Sliced

HWBRD-THC

$3.29

Add to Cart

Honey Wheat Bread - Thin Sliced

HWBRD-THN

$3.29

Add to Cart

Multi Grain Bread - Thick Sliced

MGBRD-THC

$4.29

Add to Cart

Multi Grain Bread - Thin Sliced

MGBRD-THN

$4.29

Add to Cart

Raisin Cinnamon Bread - Thick Sliced

RAIBRD-THC

$3.29

Add to Cart

Raisin Cinnamon Bread - Thin Sliced

RAIBRD-THN

$3.29

Add to Cart

Rye Bread - Thick Sliced

RBRD-THC

$3.29

Add to Cart

Rye Bread - Thin Sliced

RBRD-THN

$3.29

Add to Cart

Sourdough Bread - Thick Sliced

SBRD-THC

$3.69

Add to Cart

Sourdough Bread - Thin Sliced

SBRD-THN

$3.69

Add to Cart

White Bread - Thin Sliced

WBRD-THN

$3.29

Add to Cart

Unsliced Bread

French Bread - Unsliced

FBRD-UN

$3.29

Add to Cart

Honey Wheat Bread - Unsliced

HWBRD-UN

$3.29

Add to Cart

Multi Grain Bread - Unsliced

MGBRD-UN

$4.29

Add to Cart

Raisin Cinnamon Bread - Unsliced

RAIBRD-UN

$3.29

Add to Cart

Rye Bread - Unsliced

RBRD-UN

$3.29

Add to Cart

Sourdough Bread - Unsliced

SBRD-UN

$3.69

Add to Cart

White Bread - Unsliced

WBRD-UN

$3.29

Add to Cart

Don't see what you need? Let us know and we may add it to our product line!